Craving that perfect breakfast spread? Then, you're in luck! We're diving deep into the world of UK supermarket marmalade, tasting and rating the best of the best. This week's expert guide comes from Pam "the Jam" Corbin, a River Cottage alum and author. She emphasizes that a truly exceptional marmalade achieves perfect harmony between the peel, the gel, the texture, and, of course, the flavor.
Pam highlights the fascinating and almost magical aspect of marmalade-making: no two batches are ever exactly the same. Factors like the type of sugar used, the size of the peel, the cooking time, and even the water can significantly impact the final product. The same holds true for store-bought marmalades. While most commercial varieties include additives like pectin, acidity regulators, and orange oil, Pam notes that these aren't entirely essential and can influence the taste and texture.
Here are the top contenders:
Best Overall:
Tiptree 'Tawny' Orange Marmalade
See AlsoMattel’s First Autistic Barbie: Promoting Inclusion and RepresentationAI-Generated Weight Loss Videos: NHS Trust Exposes ScamRussia Launches 'Unstoppable' Nuke-Capable Missile That Can 'Hit London in Eight Minutes'Macclesfield's FA Cup Miracle: How They Shocked Crystal Palace!- Available at Waitrose for £2.95 (340g), that's 87p per 100g. It receives a stellar ★★★★☆ rating.
- This marmalade is a classic dark variety with a rich, caramel-orange flavor. It features generous, thick-cut pieces of chewy peel and boasts the second-highest fruit content at 47%. The ingredient list is beautifully simple: just sugar and Seville oranges, with no added pectin, making it an incredible quality choice.
Asda Extra Special Thick Cut Dark Seville Orange Marmalade
- Available at Asda for £1.86 (370g), which is just 50p per 100g. It also earns a ★★★★☆ rating.
- It offers an inviting caramel-orange aroma and plenty of medium-cut rind. With a simple recipe and 30% fruit content, it's a great option if you enjoy a dark, flavorful marmalade. Plus, it offers incredible value.
And the rest of the marmalade contenders...
M&S Fairtrade Dark Seville Orange Marmalade
- Available at Ocado for £2.25 (340g), or 66p per 100g. It also gets ★★★★☆.
- It has a classic caramel and bitter orange flavor, offering a very complex and satisfying taste. It includes extra-thick and chewy rind and 40% fruit content. It also uses Fairtrade-certified sugar.
Waitrose No 1 Vintage Marmalade
- Available at Waitrose for £3 (320g), or 94p per 100g. It also gets ★★★★☆.
- It has an aromatic scent of molasses, caramel, and bitter-orange essential oils. It's a deeply bitter marmalade, rich in flavor, with molasses adding depth and a mineral, iron-rich quality. It has a medium set and a simple recipe with sugar, oranges, molasses, and lemon comminute (whole pureed lemon), with no pectin. It's very fruit-rich, with 45% fruit.
St Dalfour Orange Fruit Spread
- Available at Waitrose for £2.50 (284g), or 88p per 100g, and at Ocado for £3.25 (284g), or £1.14 per 100g. It gets ★★★★☆.
- Labeled as a “fruit spread” due to its lower sugar content. It has an intense, candied orange aroma. It's bright orange with a very soft-set jelly and medium-cut rind that's more tender than most. It's aromatic, intensely orangey, and sour-forward, with complex, bitter orange undertones. Made from 51% oranges, plus grape and date juice concentrate.
Robertson’s Golden Shred Marmalade
- Available at Tesco for £1.90 (454g), or 42p per 100g, and at Asda for £2 (454g), or 44p per 100g. It gets ★★★☆☆.
- A nostalgic brand dating back to 1864, it offers a beautifully aromatic, crystal-clear jelly enhanced with orange oils. It has very few, very fine shreds of peel and a low 20% fruit content.
Tesco Finest Coarse Cut Dark Seville Orange Marmalade
- Available at Tesco for £1.80 (340g), or 53p per 100g. It gets ★★★☆☆.
- It's powerful on the nose with a floral, orange aroma. It's sweet on the tongue with sourness, followed by complex bitter orange. It's medium-dark, with thick-cut and firm-to-the-bite rind. Made with 30% fruit and contains caramel coloring.
Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Bitter Orange Marmalade
- Available at Sainsbury’s for £1.80 (340g), or 53p per 100g. It gets ★★★☆☆.
- It's a light marmalade with an intense aroma, likely due to the addition of orange oil. It has a classic, citric-forward twang and complex flavor with wonderfully bitter undertones and a firm-set jelly. It has al dente, medium-fine rind suspended sufficiently throughout and 30% fruit.
La Vieja Fabrica Seville Orange Fine Cut Marmalade
- Available at Morrisons and Tesco for £2.15 (365g), or 59p per 100g. It gets ★★★☆☆.
- It has a refined, aromatic, sour-forward marmalade that's balanced and complex. It's soft-set and more subtle than most of the others. Made in Seville with fine-cut oranges by a company founded in 1834. It's also fruit-rich, with 40% fruit.
Frank Cooper’s Fine Cut Oxford Marmalade
- Available at Tesco and Sainsbury’s for £3.20 (454g), or 70p per 100g. It gets ★★★☆☆.
- It has a classic, well-balanced, sour-sweet-bitter complexity, with an intense orange oil aroma. It has a smooth texture and firm set with incredibly fine-cut rind. Made with 30% fruit.
But here's where it gets controversial... The article highlights the varying fruit content in these marmalades. Does a higher fruit percentage always equate to a better marmalade? Or does the balance of other ingredients play a more crucial role? And this is the part most people miss... The impact of added ingredients. Are we sacrificing authentic flavor for shelf life and consistency?
What are your thoughts? Which marmalade is your favorite, and why? Share your opinions in the comments below – let's get a conversation started!
